"A must-have for any western RPG fan and 360 owner. A huge open world with dynamic terrain. The best bow-and-arrow gameplay I've encountered, and a fun magic system. Lots of sidequests. NPCs are stiff and there's not much exciting loot."

"Lots of great songs available for download, in addition to the good disc set. Fingering feels natural (i play real guitar) and the guitar is better designed than Guitar Hero's. All instruments are fun. The campaign is fun, but you can't avoid songs."

"This is the best war FPS game I've played. The campaign is good, and the multiplayer is even better.... with RPG-like character progression, unlocking weapons and perks (like skills). One of the best games on the 360 and XBL."

"One of the best arcade games on Xbox Live. It's like a cross between billiards and pinball. Lots of dynamics and replayability. And it's a very cheerful game... a friend joked "this game makes me feel good about myself". "

"I'm not usually into driving games, but this one goes beyond racing to include an open world and a lot of angry cops. The graphics, physics, and customization are all impressive. "

"One of my favorite all-time games. Fast-paced action in well-designed Star Wars levels with lots of dynamics. Three factions with 5 classes each. Many classes are unique: jet troopers, droidekas, battle droids, etc. Lasts months, even years."

"One of my favorite games of all time, and perhaps the most played. It's almost as fun to watch as to play. It includes two campaigns, but the best part is co-op in skirmishes and War of the Ring mode (like RISK with actual battles). Very dynamic."

"Another of my favorite games of all time. There were a lot of dynamics, so there was incentive to replay it. I would love to see a lot of the class design features be mimicked by other games."

"This might be my favorite MMO experience. It had very RP-oriented gameplay. The world's major conflict (Rebels vs Empire) was seen and felt, and I felt like a part of it. It had NPCs acting apart from player actions (like NPC stormtroopers fighting N"

"The best swordplay of any game I've played. A beautifully rendered world and tons of wandering NPCs. Climbing and acrobatics are fun and easy. Good story. But gameplay quickly gets repetitive."

"The first Halo is still the best in some ways, like having a more seamless gameplay and more open environments. But this one has a lot of replayability, too. I can't say I enjoy fragfests with strangers, but the co-op is a lot of fun."

"I liked that it was fast-paced and free-roaming. The art style was impressive without bogging down my computer. There are a number of good qualities, but, like others, it sticks to stale MMO designs."

"I loved the cinematic feel of gameplay (I played in letterbox). If you're computer can run it on High graphics, it's a very different game than on Low or Medium."

"A breath of fresh air in MMOs. I really liked the free movement, the fast action, the initial customization, the skill augmentations and other skill choices, and the non-combat NPC animations. I think I played for about 3 months, then another month w"

"A great RTS. Not my favorite RTS, but definitely one of the best."

"My first MMO, starting a few months before Luclin's release. What I admire most about it, looking back, was the complete freedom to wander wherever I pleased and that there wasn't always segregation between high-level content and low-level content. I"

Server: Drinal

"I own both this and Rock Band 2, and the latter is much better. World Tour doesn't have nearly as many songs for download. Fingering is often unnatural, obviously designed just to be difficult. And the recording studio is needlessly complicated."

"I can't wait! This is #1 on my must-have list."

"The first Diablo-clone I played. It just didn't grab me like Diablo 2, but it wasn't a bad game."

"It's hard to describe, but somehow this game fell short of Diablo 2's gameplay for me. Part of it was the ragdoll deaths that didn't seem to be in response to my attacks. The skills didn't grab me as much as D2's either."

"I played it a bit in beta. The art is impressive. The short in-camera custcenes were cool. But it's mostly a repeat of stale designs."

"I loved the runestone system. I still like the idea of RP-based PvP, though my experience was that this game's RvR fell into more of a Counterstrike mentality (kills were not really roleplay-based)."

"Hokey storyline and it didn't live up to Diablo 2. Not a terrible game though."

"I played it in beta. It wasn't a bad game, I didn't end up buying it after release."

"My least favorite MMO. I quit pretty quickly."

"Red Alert was the best, but I also liked Generals. I played mostly solo."